Why Robots Fall Down

Larry Goldfarb

Larry Goldfarb

· 4 min read
Mind in Motion - Why Robots Fall Down

Life is like riding a bicycle.
To keep your balance,
you must keep moving.
— Albert Einstein

In 1993, I delivered the keynote address at Cybernetics in the Art of Learning, the American Society for Cybernetics annual conference in Philadelphia. The talk, titled Why Robots Fall Down, explored the link between cybernetics and human movement coordination, which was initially highlighted in Norbert Wiener’s Cybernetics in 1948. 

Wiener’s work discusses the role of kinesthetic perception in guiding movement, arguing that we cannot think about perceptions merely as inputs and movement as outputs. Instead, we must consider the nervous system as an integrated whole, where circular causality, in general, and feedback, in particular, govern sensory-motor correlation.

My presentation built on this legacy by incorporating the findings from recent research in kinesiology, neurophysiology, and physical medicine to propose an understanding of the role of feedback in movement. Building on the original insights of cybernetics and presenting research findings from three different areas of investigation — posture, balance, and disease — I offered a report from the field, expanding on cybernetic themes to provide insight into the complexity of human movement and the nature of learning.

After the talk, I led the group through a short Awareness Through Movement lesson. Heinz von Foerster and Humberto Maturana gave formal comments on the paper, followed by a discussion with the audience. 

Jude Lombardi recently digitized the video she recorded during the talk and follow-on discussion, which she posted to YouTube. You can watch the video by clicking on this link.

Since the beginning of my presentation is missing from the recording, we have made the full text available on the Mind in Motion Online (MIMO) website. To access it, follow these steps:

  1. Log in to your MIMO account.
  2. Go to the “Library” section.
  3. Find the “Wrestling for Higher Consciousness” category.
  4. Look under “Documents” for the file.

If you don’t have a MIMO account, you can get one for free here. This account gives you access to this document and a collection of complimentary Awareness Through Movement lesson recordings. Feldenkrais teachers and trainees are eligible for a professional “Become a Better Teacher” account, which offers additional resources, including hundreds of ATM transcripts, at no cost.

Image

This Sunday, 17 March 2024, I will present Embodied Feedback: Second-Order Cybernetics and Somatics at the monthly American Society for Cybernetics online meeting. 

Classic cybernetics has long relied on the nervous system’s control of movement to illustrate how communication and self-regulation function. Second-order cybernetics evolved to explore the nature of observing systems and how we, as observers, influence and construct our perceptions. This shift in perspective parallels the development of somatics, which considers the body as experienced from within, from physical therapy and bodywork.

However, somatics has yet to appreciate the role of cybernetic circuitry fully and needs a systemic framework to understand mind-body connections, sensations, self-image, attitudes, and abilities. On the other hand, cybernetics can be too abstract and removed from subjective experience.

Therefore, my presentation aims to address the following questions:

  • How can these approaches learn and benefit from each other?
  • Can a second-order approach help us understand the surprising physical transformations somatics can bring about?
  • Can body-based exploration ground conceptual understanding of our lived experiences?

If you are interested in attending the talk, please sign up here. There is no charge.

The program starts at 9:00 AM US Eastern time. (To find out when the event is happening where you are, please click here.)

Image

The photo at the top of this post is a snapshot from the video of me giving the keynote address mentioned above

Mind in Motion Online parag Separator

Your thoughts?

Please let us know your perspective! Add your comments, reactions, suggestions, ideas, etc., by first logging in to your Mind in Motion account and then clicking here.

Commenting on blog posts is available to anyone with a Mind in Motion Online account.

  • Join in by getting your free account, which gives you access to the e-book edition of Articulating Changes (Larry’s now-classic Master’s thesis), ATM® lessons, and more — all at no charge whatsoever.
  • To find out more and sign up, please click here.
  • Want to share this blog post with a friend? You can email them the web address shown in your browser. Or share the post via social media by clicking on one of the following icons:
Creative Commons Button 

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License

[This license gives you permission to copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format for any purpose, even commercially. You may also remix, transform, and build upon the material. You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made.]

Responses:


  • Bob Boyd -March 15, 2024

    Larry, You said in the email the event starts at 9am Eastern, yet eventbrite puts at 12:00pm ?



  • Larry Goldfarb -March 15, 2024

    Thanks for asking, Bob. The event does start at noon Eastern time. (It's 9 AM Pacific, which is when I have to be there. Sorry for the confusion.)


Please Log in to comment

© 2025 Mind in Motion, All rights reserved.

Feldenkrais®, Feldenkrais Method®, Functional Integration®, and Awareness Through Movement® are registered service marks; Guild Certified Feldenkrais Teacher® and Guild Certified Feldenkrais Practitioner® are certification marks of the Feldenkrais Guild® of North America.

Feldenkrais, Méthode Feldenkrais, Prise de Conscience par le Mouvement, Intégration Fonctionnelle sont des termes déposés par Feldenkrais France.

I termini Metodo Feldenkrais, Conoscersi Attraverso il Movimento, Consapevolezza Attraverso il Movimento, Integrazione Funzionale, Feldenkrais sono marchi registrati di proprietà dell'AIIMF.

Feldenkrais Method® is the registered trademark in the U.K. of the Feldenkrais Guild UK Ltd., Reg No. 1563759.

Feldenkrais, Gilde lizenzierte/r Feldenkrais-LehrerIn, Feldenkrais-Lehrer FVD, Feldenkrais-Lehrerin FVD, Feldenkrais-Practitioner FVD und FVD sind die registrierten Wortmarken für den FVD Feldenkrais-Verband Deutschland e.V.